Another great article that I read recently and have definitely been mulling over:
click hereThomas Friedman's latest article about Generation Q has got my mind running!
I don't think I can handle analyzing the writing without putting in some of my own opinions on the content. Anyways, here goes:
I loved the core of his lede: "...the more I am around this generation of college students, the more I am both baffled and impressed"
This sentence appeals to a great variety of audiences. The contradiction between being baffled and impressed raises some skepticism and curiosity for students about whom he is writing as well as the parent generation and even grandparent generation who probably have similar feelings. He explains nicely in the next line:
"I am impressed because they are so much more optimistic and idealistic than they should be. I am baffled because they are so much less radical and politically engaged than they need to be."
To be honest, I'm not sure if I am flattered by my generation's optimism or offended by his perception of our apathy toward social and political activism.
First, he flatters us:
He talks about our involvement as students and young people in the workforce in the wake of September 11th and its subsequent events. His discussion of increased travel for my generation, particularly in the dimension of study abroad appealed to me. As a Kalamazoo College student among the 86% of my peers who studied abroad, I definitely support his mention of intercultural understanding as a crucial aspect for the future.
He also addresses my generation's enthusiasm for volunteer work. Perhaps it is in this light of "diving deeper than ever" that my generation strives for personal satisfaction in our work rather than fame and glory. Programs like "Teach for America" and Peace Corps are, like he said, increasingly popular - I see it in my own college's daily campus announcements.
I suppose that after those notes, he is justified in referring to us as "Generation Q - the Quiet Americans, in the best sense of that term, quietly pursuing their idealism, at home and abroad." Beautifully written - I do feel a sense of pride to be referred to as one such Generation Q-er.
I also understand his following argument of GenQ as too quiet and too online for our own good. We have been raised under the notion that everything can happen with just the press of a button in an increasingly wireless world; my generation faces serious potential to fall into the trap of living solely through a screen and keyboard. And as a personal observation, too many students have already begun "plugging out of life" as quoted by a friend of mine. Initially, the phrase was in reference to the newest iPod or other small gadget which allows one to become absorbed in something other than real life. It seems that my generation is definitely taking the quiet path, partly because we are marching to the beat of a different drum from our earbuds.
Friedman suggests that GenQ "would be doing itself a favor, and America a favor, if it demanded from every candidate that comes on campus to answer three questions: What is your plan for mitigating climate change? What is your plan for reforming Social Security? What is your plan for dealing with the deficit - so we all won't be working for China in 20 years?" It's a good suggestion for us to be so demanding. His references to GenQ e-mailing and mouse clicking our way into politics are frightening. But I wonder to what credibility we sign on to such online petitions that supposedly save the world.
Friedman concluded by reverting back to his original scene of college campus visits. A statue is what impressed him most. I really liked the symbolism of that. The substance of this statue is so dynamically different from any sort of online Google or Wikipedia article that tells the story of a courageous man. Under this conclusion, I can see that Friedman's ideas fall with the solid forms of courage and confidence in students - exactly that which is praised us for earlier in the piece.
There is substance to the power of that statue. So, when he praises us for our quiet convictions in humanitarian work and grassroots passions, he is trying to stimulate my generation to get involved in tried and true ways of changing the world.
Another great article by Thomas Friedman - thanks!
For more reflections, check out the responses that followed Sunday's publication of this article by
clicking here.